The 3 Most Common Mattress Buying Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
Buying a mattress can feel overwhelming - there are endless options, price points, and opinions. At Bed Depot, we’ve helped thousands of Kiwis find their perfect mattress, and we’ve seen the same mistakes pop up again and again. To help you shop smarter and sleep better, here are the top five mattress buying mistakes (and how to avoid them).
1. Choosing the Wrong Firmness for Your Sleep Style
It’s tempting to just go with what feels “comfortable” in the moment, but the right firmness depends on how you sleep:
Side sleepers usually need a softer mattress to cushion shoulders and hips.
Back sleepers benefit from medium-firm support to keep their spine aligned.
Stomach sleepers typically need a firmer mattress to prevent back strain.
✅ Avoid it: Try before you buy if you can, or get in contact with us to determine your sleep style to guide your decision.
2. Overlooking What’s Inside the Mattress
Not all mattresses are created equal, even if they feel similar at first. Look beyond the top layer:
Is it pocket-sprung or foam?
Does it have cooling gel or memory foam?
✅ Avoid it: Ask the questions - do you get hot or cold at night? Quality construction = longer life and better sleep.
3. Forgetting to Measure Your Space (and Bed Base!)
This one sounds obvious, but it’s easy to miss:
Will the mattress fit up the stairs or through your hallway?
Is the bed for you or for two?
Does your bed base support the weight of a new mattress?
Are you sure you’re upgrading from a queen to a king, not a super king?
✅ Avoid it: Grab a tape measure before you shop. If in doubt, bring your dimensions in - we’ll help you match the right size and style.